There are many times when Forester articulates the differences in expectation of behavior of the English in Rome versus in England quite clearly. It is found more subtly through reactions, descriptions, and dialogue. There are two moments when we see the true, whimsical nature of Lucy that show the contrast between Rome and England expectations. The first is on page 73, the surprise, passionate kiss Lucy receives from George. Although Mrs. Bartlett witnesses the kiss there is no outward dialogue in this moment. It is almost as if, since they are in Rome Mrs. Bartlett accepts the beauty of the moment instead of condemning the behavior. Once they are back in England Mrs. Bartlett suddenly has plenty to say about the situation. Additionally, when they arrive back to England there is scene between Mr. Beebe, the clergyman, and Cecil, Lucy’s betrothed. Mr. Beebe is describing the way Lucy plays the piano. He watched her play while they were in Rome and was enamored at the fact that she had so much passion within her and yet that passion is regularly stifled. He says, ” Does it seem reasonable that she play so wonderfully, and live so quietly?” He goes on to say, ” The water-tight compartments in her will break down, and music and life will mingle.” (Forester 100) Beebe sees that Lucy is playing the role expected of her as a proper English young lady. He sees that inside Lucy is passion, and emotions that are unacceptable in her culture. He himself seems to admire the passion within Lucy in Rome more than the proper behavior she exhibits in England. He looks forward to the day when her passion bursts from her seems and she is able to live the life she wants to. It’s a great comparison of behaviors, feelings, and expectations in the different cities.
-Travelin’ Tori
Image from:
Oscar Vault Monday – A Room with a View, 1986 (dir. James Ivory)
Mie Belle Avventure 